Hardwood flooring is often considered the epitome of luxury. But is it always the best choice? We compared hardwood vs carpet floor to help you understand the pros and cons of both types of floors.
When is hardwood appropriate and when is a carpet floor going to be a better solution?
1. What room?
One of the most important things to consider when you are trying to decide between hardwood floors and carpet floors is the type of room that they will be installed in. Is it for the living room, bedroom, kitchen, den or bathroom?
Let’s make it clear now, neither hardwood nor carpet are actually great options for wet areas like bathrooms and kitchens. Those floors are susceptible to humidity and will easily get stained or damaged if you spill something on them.
But both hardwood and carpet are great flooring solutions for living areas like the bedroom, an office or dining room. Then can pretty much be installed anywhere in the home so which way to go will mostly depend on your design style and tastes.
Carpet floors are often ideal for bedrooms because they are soft and retain warmth so it’s a lot more comfortable to walk barefoot on. They also absorb sound which makes for great noise-free rooms.
On the other hand, hardwood floors are great for living and dining rooms. They are more resistant to stains and damage than carpet which makes them the perfect choice for areas that have more traffic.
2. What budget?
One of the biggest decision-factor when choosing flooring for your home is obviously price. Depending on your budget, one type of floor might be better than the other for you.
Carpet usually comes at much lower prices than hardwood. Price per square foot for carpet flooring goes from $1.50 on the lower end to $5+ for higher quality, durable carpets.
On the other end, hardwood runs anywhere from $5 to $20/sq. ft. depending on the type of wood. You can also find quality discount hardwood flooring in speciality flooring stores starting as low as $2.40 per square foot.
Something else to take into consideration is the cost of hardwood flooring installation vs carpet flooring. Carpet is easier to install and most people with average DIY skills can install them on their own. Hardwood floors are more complicated so it’s usually best to get professional flooring installation contractors if you want the best results
Although hardwood flooring is the most expensive option now, it also has the higher value in the long run. If properly taken care of, hardwood will last forever. You will never have to replace your floors and hardwood adds resale value to your home. Meanwhile, carpet is now as durable which means you will most likely need to replace them several times over the years.
3. What lifestyle?
Here are some questions to ask yourself to help you decide if carpet or hardwood floors are the right choice.
- How many people live in the house?
- Do you have pets?
- Do you have young children?
- Is the room a high traffic area?
- How much maintenance are you prepared for?
If you have a full household, young children and/or pets, carpet floors may not be the ideal choice. In high traffic areas, you might want to choose solid hardwood that will last longer and be more resistant to stains or damage.
Carpet also requires more maintenance efforts to keep clean. In addition to regular vacuuming, you’ll need to get professional carpet cleaning on a regular basis (at least once or twice a year). Hardwood floors are easy to maintain in stellar condition and only requires refinishing or polishing once in a while.